Lost Update – Telephone Line
Posted by LOTGK on April 25, 2008

Lost Update Season IV 04/24/2008
Hello… how are you
Have you been alright, through all those lonely lonely nights,
That’s what I’d say, I’d tell you everything,
If you’d pick up that telephone.
Hey–how you feelin’
Are you still the same
Don’t you realize the things we did were all for real not a dream,
I just can’t believe
They’ve all faded out of view.
Telephone line, give me some time, I’m living in twilight
With the writers strike stopping production for several months, ABC Lost went on hiatus for several weeks and tonight, a new episode has aired. in the past several weeks, I have had time to explore my theory a little more in depth and with four remaining episodes left to season IV, my theory looks pretty solid.
Just what is my theory….. I’ll tell you in a Lost island minute.
Although it appears the survivors of Oceanic flight 815 are on a tropical island, they are being deceived. There is no island. The survivors are in a virtual reality laboratory. All the castaways are interconnected to one another sharing each others thoughts, memories, and feelings. While in this virtual reality laboratory, a battery of physical and mental experiments are performed on them. And who is behind all this other than the mysterious government men? Aliens of course.
RING…RING…RING… Code 14J…Code 14J.
The phone rings in the hut where John, Hurley, and Sawyer are.
It’s the code signaling that one of the others have been captured.
Alex enters the code of 1622 to let the mercenaries from the freighter into the compound.
Ben wakes up in the desert. He’s shot. He kills the two would be captures.
He checks into a hotel under the name Moriarity, Sherlock Holmes nemesis.
Ben meets Sayid in Iraq. Team up to kill the man who murdered Sayid’s wife.
The mercenaries have Alex. They use her in an attempt to lure Ben from the compound. Ben resists and Alex is murdered. Ben states that he changed the rules.
Ben goes into a secret room in the compound, and a minute later, the smoke monster enters the compound and attacks the mercenaries.
Ben is in the year 2005, October. He seeks Charles Widmore. He tells him he’s not there to kill him, but his daughter, Penny.
When is a relative term!!!!
Ben and John need Hurley to contact Jacob. Why?
Three castaways are murdered in the crossfire.
Jack is sick.
Enough of the recap, lets discuss the smoke monster. Ben somehow releases the smoke monster from a hidden room in the compound. Remember, Alex shut down the force field keeping it at bay. (Why didn’t it attack at that moment? When the force shield was deactivated?)
Tonight we saw a good portion of the smoke monster. Not just a quick glimpse passing by. This thing rolled into camp at a high rate of speed. It was a concentrated mass. It moved like a snake or serpent in roller coaster fashion. It did not attack the others, only the mercenary soldiers. And it dispatched them very quickly. The monster actually dragged one of the soldiers into the thicket of smoke.
At this point, the monster is not their imagination. It is not just a wisp of smoke floating on the island. It is not just all in their heads. It is a supernatural entity. This monster is not part of the normal everyday island life on any known place in the world.
My theory of virtual reality fits this scenario very well. Ben is in total control of his surroundings. At all times. Even when he appears to be a captive, he is exactly where he wants to be. Notice when John and Sawyer came in to the room while Ben played the piano. When told the news, Ben opens up the bench seat and pulls a loaded sawed off shot gun out. He could have escaped any time. He also had the secret passaged in the compound where he could have escaped at any time.
he also controls the smoke monster as evident tonight when he summons it to the compound to attack the soldiers. He knew exactly when it was coming and where it was going. Ben is in total control of everything. Perhaps like Desmond, Ben also has the ability to peer into the future, but unlike Desmond, Ben doesn’t see flashes, but entire scenes.
Ben has a plan. And it is to win the castaways over. Make it appear that he is the good guy. Saving them from the evil people from the freighter is part of the plan. But remember, Ben always lies. Always.
And what happens when Ben kills Penny? Desmonds anchor?
Until next week Lost fans!
LURKING ON THE GRASSY KNOLL



Grassy Knoll RSS

Lost N Plenty said
I think Ben travels back to the future. He uses that room to do it from. He was on the desery ground when he woke up. He was in 2005 then. A year after the plance crash. The smoke monster is time reversing itself.
KathyL said
I think they are all in the past and Ben is reliving the sequence over and over like he’s in hell. When Alex was shot, the rules changed, and the outcome would be different. Now Ben goes to the mainland to even the score and take the life of Mr. Widmore’s daughter Penelope.
wineymomma said
Except that Ben didn’t know that the merc was going to kill Alex…Maybe he just missed that scene.
Lost Fan said
Thats why Ben said that Widmore changed the rules. Ben knew Alex wouldn;t get shot and was surprised when she did. I believe Ben can go back in time and change events and this time Alex will escape and won’t be shot.
Cameron said
I Think that your right about the smoke monster summond by Ben but i also think that Jacob the man in the cabin controls the whole thing or is apart of it or something because ben said you can ask jacob all about it when they get there so if he controls it or is apart of it he should know all about it besides they both Jacob and the monster are supernatural in some way.And i also think something is going on with sawyer because he seems to care about people more he risked his life to save claire and he threatened Locke that if he hurt Hurley he would kill the bastard.(Claire and hurley where both close people to Charley and sawyer felt bad about his death so maybe that has something to do with it.)
Lori said
Most exciting episode EVER!!
I was on the edge of my seat through most of it!
I think Ben being shocked by Alex’s death was an act.
I think the rules were that they cant mess with eachothers kids.
and by telling them that she wasnt his daughter, it gave him an open to kill her.
I was crying so hard when it happened.
The Dannielle/Alex storyline was one of the most interesting.
and now its over
of course we always have flashbacks.
We never saw Dannielles flashback!!
wineymomma said
I like the time travel changing the rules bit…could be…and maybe the no messing with each other’s kids is also a part of it too…the two theories combined work for me!
rob said
very interesting about penny being desmond’s constant. if she dies then desmond must too right?
Paul said
I think Desmond is ok for the moment…maybe he only needs the constant when he crosses back…so if Penny dies before he gets back to the island….then he dies….then the scientist guy could die too since Desmond is his constant….craziness
Lori said
Id like to know how Ben gets anyone to follow him?
he NEVER answers ANY questions about ANYTHING!!!
6-10 Worker said
Ben has a power over all of them. A secret only he knows. He uses that to control the people to follow him.
2008monster said
I really like this comment”: The smoke monster is time reversing itself” it really opend my eyes on the whole lost theorie/storie, it has to do with time traveling and that ben controls all of it, if you see all the hints in the serie and experiments that Ben did with his people and linked them to movies like: back to the future, 12 monkeys, time machine and the langoliers from Stephen king., you realize those stories from all those movies can be found in LOST, it’s possible that the eiland is stuck in a wormhole and ben uses the right coordinates to acces it.
The smoke is a giant langolier! I really love it, thanks
Daniel Winnard said
Hi
I love this website, and like reading about all the theories that are cropping up.
I think the island is similar to the film The Truman Show. Which is why people cannot get off the island and why desmond stayed on the same course and ended up back at the island.
Everytime Truman tried to leave they through something up to make them stay. Like a storm etc. I believe the others are actors. Like the truman show. They do what ever they can to keep the people on the island. Storylines are plotted by the director Jacob or Ben.
I havent had much time to think about this theory i just thought maybe some people could help elaborate it.
Might be a totally wacky idea but would be interested to see if people agreed or disagreed on my randomness.
LOTGK said
Daniel, yes, the Truman show was brought up several times. An interesting concept. I have a few questions about it however. As in, several people get shot and died on the island. Shannon, Libby, Ana Lucia, etc,. I don’t know if I were an actor if I would sign on for that type of role. To die.
However, in a virtual reality world, no one dies, no one gets hurt, it’s all in your mind.
Thanks for commenting and welcome.